Tuesday, 13 November 2012

Sexual assault: an issue for women in ecology? Or for everybody, everywhere?

I am, by nature, an optimistic person with a positive outlook on life.  Any experience I have, whether good or bad, I manage to find a beneficial consequence.  This blog post is not so much about being a woman in ecology, but about being a person.  More specifically, a person who has been subjected to sexual assault and how this can impact a positive attitude to life and work.  It just so happens that my life and work is ecology and conservation.  I suppose sexual assault is a topic more commonly associated with impacting people of my gender, but I would like to propose that it is not, and that ignorance of this fact is, if anything, making everyone more vulnerable.

My Story 
Alone at night in a developing country – was I asking for it?

Let me give you some history.  I am a woman.  I work in conservation, primarily in the developing world.  Recently, I spent six months living and working in Sinai, Egypt.  As a western woman living in a small but relatively touristy town, despite always wearing modest clothes (at least by my standards, i.e. covering my shoulders and upper arms and my legs to at least below the knee), I was subject to constant attention, from wolf whistles and honking cars to frankly obscene comments.  All of this was irritating, but didn’t really feel threatening and was just something I tried to ignore and reduce the provocation for as much as possible.  Incidentally, the one time I covered my head with a scarf, I was openly laughed at.

 One evening, I was walking home from seeing friends.  It was dark, but as Egypt gets dark between 5 and 6.30pm throughout the year, this was not something that could be avoided so was not usually a problem.  It was full moon, and for once the wind that usually tears through the Gulf of Aqaba had abated and the sea was beautifully calm.  I chose to walk home along the quieter sea front to enjoy the peaceful sound of the waves before I got back to my dark and stuffy home.  There is only a small portion of the seafront that lacks street lamps or doesn’t pass in front of either restaurants or houses, so I didn’t think I would be in any danger.

However, as I rounded a corner onto the only dark strip, I saw a man standing facing the wall.  I assumed he was urinating (not uncommon) and ignoring him, kept walking.  From what happened next, I had clearly been mistaken.  The details are unnecessary, but suffice to say, I believe I escaped rape only through good luck, my level-headedness and a few choice words of my very basic Arabic, which maybe illustrated that I was not ‘just’ a young tourist who would leave without telling anybody.

The Consequences
Freedom, confidence and trust stolen

I was extremely fortunate to escape with relatively little physical or emotional harm, but the consequences have stayed with me.  For the following couple of weeks, I was unable to walk down the street past young Egyptian men calling out their usual ‘greetings’ without my heart racing, my chest going tight and struggling to breathe.  As I had not got a good look at my attacker’s face, he could have been any of those people I walked past on a daily basis.  My implicit trust in human nature was damaged, and has still not been fully repaired.

Whereas I used to feel confident and almost invincible, I lost the freedom I used to feel to be able to do anything or go anywhere I wanted.  I wondered how many other women it affected; if it could happen to me then surely it could happen to anyone, and not everybody would feel they could tell someone.  I thought of the thousands of women who are assaulted everyday, all too often in ways much worse than me, and how that must affect the collective psyche of women on earth.

I don’t want sexual assault to be a taboo subject.  I don’t want women who have experienced it to feel that they are alone or that they cannot overcome the consequences.  On the other hand, I do not try to pretend that I have any notion of what it is to deal with cases worse than mine.

The Other Side – An Egyptian males view
Are some women provoking the assault of others without knowing?

When I described what had happened to me to a male Egyptian friend, he was sorry, but gave me an insight into the other side of the story.  As a diving instructor, he claimed that he and his friends experienced sexual abuse at the hands of western women on a regular basis.  He said that, all too often, women came to Egypt to dive, to get drunk and to have sex with young Egyptian men.  They would seemingly purposefully change directly in front of their dive guides and make sexually explicit comments.  After a days diving, my friend received a phone call from his client saying, “Where do you live? I’m coming to have sex with you.”  Other women regularly touch their dive guides inappropriately underwater where they can do little to defend themselves.  One woman, whilst my friend was driving her to a dive site, apparently grabbed his crotch.

The majority of dive guides and instructors come from distant parts of Egypt, which are often more conservative than the town I stayed in, and infinitely more than the western world.  If they are not married, many of these men have never even held a girl’s hand, let alone had any kind of sexual relationship, so the presence of young women in bikinis, drinking and dancing provocatively in bars in the evenings and coming on to them is understandably extremely uncomfortable and disturbing.  To the naïve newcomer, the overriding perception of a western woman is one with very few morals who is happy to have sex with any person at any time.  So is it really surprising that my attacker considered it acceptable to do what he did to me?

The sexual assault and rape of women in Egypt, both Egyptian and others, is a relatively well-publicised problem.  But I have never heard any mention of the abuse tourists inflict on the men they visit, which is potentially an equal if not greater problem.  Additionally, it can only exacerbate the potential for abuse of women.

Looking Forward
Consequences for my career, and maybe yours too

After my experience in Egypt (although I should state that I believe it could just as easily have occurred in Britain, or anywhere else in the world I have worked), I no longer feel happy to walk home alone after dark, or in places I do not know.  As a woman working in ecology and conservation in the developing world, I often have to work unusual hours in remote places in cultures very different from my own.  Whereas before I would have gone into these places carefree, now I might think twice, only go with other people or at certain times, or even not at all. 

Sometimes I am angry with the person who attacked me for taking that freedom away from me.  But other times I am grateful.  I came away relatively unharmed, but more aware of the potential dangers in the world.  Perhaps my awareness now will prevent something far worse happening to me in the future.  And I hope that by sharing my story, I might make some of you other seemingly invincible young women (and men) a little more cautious and safe, and maybe think a little about the image of western women you contribute to when working in different cultures.  As I said, I always try to find a positive outcome from every experience.


What do you think?

I do not claim to be an expert on any of the topics covered in this blog.  I speak only from my own experience and from discussions with friends, male and female, British and Egyptian, so I would love to hear anyone else's thoughts or experiences which are relevant.

5 comments:

  1. Hi Mariel, firstly, I think that the fact that you have shared your story is really brave and also quite inspiring. We do often feel so invincible and it just isn't the case.

    I would like to share a couple of experiences, that were not as extreme, but hopefully not completely irrelevant...

    I have been travelling to developing countries alone since the age of 18. I am lucky to not have experienced what happened to you, but I think that I could have come close. I also believe that it is important to be aware of the potential dangers and realise that we are not invincible.

    When I was 19 I spent a few weeks working at a ‘rehabilitation centre’ in Ecuador. For the first week I was the only volunteer, the only westerner and the only female living on site. I also spoke very little Spanish. This perhaps ultimately boils down to naivety, but I did go through a volunteer organisation and this was not what I expected, nor what was advertised. The owner of the centre used to frequently hold my hand when we were alone and often attempt to kiss me. This made me highly uncomfortable, but I felt like I would be being offensive to express my discomfort. I thought that maybe it was cultural. Being in that situation (although nothing other than that happened) was incredibly intimidating. I felt completely helpless.

    A similar situation occurred when I was in Peru with a guide that lead me off into the forest. There were people only a hundred metres (ish) away and again, I felt completely helpless.

    I do think however, that the scariest situation that I have been in happened where I grew up in Norwich. Again, it could have been a lot worse but my confidence was severely bruised.

    Every time I set off by myself on a new adventure I feel a bit terrified. Even just walking somewhere alone in the dark my heart also pounds and my palms begin to sweat. I worry that my luck is going to run out at some point. That may sound ridiculous, but it is always in the back of my mind, as I feel like I may have had some close shaves. I love travelling and I hope to do conservation work in developing countries, but there is a part of me that is genuinely incredibly frightened to do so. It is good to be aware of the potential dangers and I am definitely a lot less naive! But I hate how afraid that I have become, especially since these situations were nothing compared to what so many other women have and do experience every day.

    I guess that you can never fully protect yourself from these kinds of situations, except to be aware. I remember feeling a multiple of emotions during and after these situations, but I don’t think that you should ever feel like you ‘asked for it’, which is how I was made to feel by some people. Should I have been wondering off by myself into the forest with the 50 year old Peruvian? Maybe not, but I did. I guess that what I would take away from my own experiences is that you can only learn from these situations, try to avoid them in the future and not let the fear of it (or something worse) happening again completely control what you do or don’t do.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and experiences, Heather. What you say about hating how afraid you have become really resonates with me, because I think that is what I now dislike most about my experience. I feel like I should be free to work wherever and whenever I want, but in reality, that isn't wise or safe. I'm interested to know if any men feel like that, either because of the risk of sexual assault or any other dangers?

      Delete
  2. I wonder how much it is to do with being far from our contacts and safety networks, family and friends, who we can run things by and check whether we're taking too many risks. In many fieldwork situations we're not only very far away but with little or no communication for weeks on end.

    On the flip side, having spent time working in Borneo, most days in the field on my own with a male field assistant I felt incredibly safe. The field manager (Ed Turner) is a fantastic guy and I really trusted his judgement in hiring staff. I guess it's good to have some point of contact that you can trust, perhaps even asking for references / reviews from other volunteers before heading out on your own.

    Thanks so much for this brave retelling Mariel, and for your stories too Heather.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mariel,
    It's nice to read your blog and be able to relate to you.

    Last year I went to Italy, embarking on a new adventure to study there. I arrived in the country early in thinking I could do some Au pair work until my course started. However, after a bit of a culture shock regarding the more wealthy citizens, I realised I couldn't stay for much longer and ended up being rescued by an Italian friend who lived in a slightly down graded part of town. It wasn't rough and I didn't feel uncomfortable walking the streets. At this point I was still unfamiliar with the language and my confidence was lacking because of it.

    One particular evening in the summer, I took a walk to the local park. I wasn't wearing anything provocative yet I was listening to my music. I became fully aware of a guy following me. Every time I looked around he would change direction. Until it got to the point that he was so close that I stopped to let him pass. After an awkward exchange of looks, I walked on and took my phone out, but I had no one to call. It was daylight, there were joggers around, yet only twenty steps later did he make his move in grabbing my bum. I lost it and started shouting and cursing in English to him. Enough to make him scoot pretty fast.

    I was lucky that it was nothing more than a bum grope, yet I felt so violated and angry. I was angry with myself,I just wanted to chase him and punch him. Once arriving back to the house, I explained to the Italian mother the best I could in my broken Italian. She was horrified and only then did it hit me. Yet, when I spoke to people at home about it they often made it in to a joke about how Italian's have a reputation for touching women's bums. This made me all the more angry because I knew it wasn't true. I had got to know many Italian men who were all respectable and wouldn't even consider such a move.

    It took me a very long time to feel comfortable going out on my own again. Very soon after that I moved towns and rekindled my love for Italy. However, even now if I think too much about it, it creeps me out and I wonder how far it could have gone.

    It's very interesting to hear the other side of the story. I think western women have a reputation in many places. Society gets caught up in vicious circles.

    Thanks for sharing your experience and also your time spent reflecting.
    Katy

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete